Serendipity3 Frrrozen Hot Chocolate Mix vs Swiss Miss Simply Cocoa

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. How we make money.

Quick verdict

Swiss Miss Simply Cocoa edges it overall, winning 2 of 4 rating categories. Swiss Miss Simply Cocoa is cheaper to start ($4 vs $15).

Choose Serendipity3 Frrrozen Hot Chocolate Mix if…

You’re making the famous NYC frozen hot chocolate at home. The mix behind the New York café’s signature frozen drink. Intense dark chocolate with a light espresso-like finish.

Check price
Choose Swiss Miss Simply Cocoa if…

You’re a short, simple ingredient list at a budget price. A cleaner-label version of the classic with no artificial preservatives. Silky flavor, though a bit thin.

Check price

Side by side

Serendipity3 Frrrozen Hot Chocolate MixSwiss Miss Simply Cocoa
Our rating4.2/54.3/5
Flavor4.4/54/5
Richness & body4.4/53.4/5
Value3.5/54.8/5
Ease4.3/54.8/5
Typical price$15$4
Size1 canister8 packets
Cost per unitvariesabout 50¢ per packet
TypeFrozen hot chocolate mixHot cocoa mix
StyleDarkMilk chocolate
Make withBlend with milk and iceWith milk
Best forMaking the famous NYC frozen hot chocolate at homeA short, simple ingredient list at a budget price

Serendipity3 Frrrozen Hot Chocolate Mix: pros & cons

  • Intense chocolate flavor
  • Fun summer treat
  • Pricey
  • Needs a blender

Read the full Serendipity3 Frrrozen Hot Chocolate Mix review

Swiss Miss Simply Cocoa: pros & cons

  • Simple ingredients
  • Inexpensive
  • Good aroma
  • Somewhat thin
  • Still sweet

Read the full Swiss Miss Simply Cocoa review